Home Contact New York News Photos 1 2 Reviews Sports Web Finds
Your Host
Site Tools
Categories
Archive
Greatest Hits
Photos
Interviews
Search



PaulKatcher.com
All of Web
Monday, October 3, 2005

The 2005 Yankees: How the East Was Won
No team in American sports is paid attention to like the New York Yankees, and it's not even close.

I read and hear stuff like, "It can't be any fun to be a Yankees fan, because they always win." That's usually followed up with a rag about how they haven't been winning, at least in terms of World Series titles since 2000, when they polished off a run of four in five years.

Yeah, sucks to be us! But you know why it's fun? Because everyone cares.

The AL-record 4,090,440 fans who showed up at Yankee Stadium this year, at an average of 50,499 per game, cared. The ML-leading 81.9%-full road stadiums when the Yanks came to town cared. There's nothing in sports like it.

Notre Dame has a similar caché in college football, but that sport doesn't grip the nation like Major League Baseball, which set another attendance record this season. Most people who admit to hating the Irish probably can't name more than three current players. Hell, no more than the coach, probably. However, most people who hate the Yankees can probably name at least five of the 10 players making at least $10 million this season.

The Los Angeles Lakers? The Dallas Cowboys? You can combine the nationwide press those high-profile franchises get, and it would total a fraction of the columns written about the Yankees.

If you're a Yankees fan, you're part of sports royalty. The pinnacle of American sports. There's no one challenging that perch atop America's sports consciousness. That's why it's fun.

Now, let's get to some quick-hits:

THE YANKEES-RED SUX FINAL THREE-GAME SERIES

• I almost previewed this series with the headline Armageddon Part III (Probably of IV), because you had to figure a third straight seven-game ALCS was in the cards to torment those who dinn't already love five years off their lives from the previous two.

• Cleveland's run of losses, all at home against a team with nothing to play for, including that Friday night game in which I think Chicago's starting outfield consisted of S.D. Jones, Frankie Williams and the Brooklyn Brawler? Biggest choke ever, right?

• With the exception of booze-hound Chris House, admirably admonished by Sux fans, the 19 games these teams played really focused on baseball. Of course, winning was paramount with neither exactly coasting. And how 'bout playing a final series in which both were pretty happy with the outcome?

• If the Yanks and Sux fans could ever agree on anything, it's this: What in god's name was FOX doing splitting the screen Saturday to show our game and the Cleveland-Chicago game and, worse, giving us the audio to that suck-fest?

• Walk David Ortiz like the NL does Barry Bonds? Are you nuts? Let me know the next time Bonds has a guy like Manny Ramirez hitting behind him, and we'll see how many times he walks.

• The shirts say AL EAST CHAMPS. We're AL East champs. Period. What, you wanna play a tie-breaker, fuck up both teams' rotations and not give anyone a day's rest? Yeah, that makes sense. We're both going on the road anyway, and we deserve to finish is first place, because we're the Yankees (see above).

THE AL MVP RACE

• Alex Rodriguez is the most talented Yankee since Mickey Mantle. His batting prowess is well-documented, but his awareness and smarts in the field and on the bases is something to behold, and I have no idea whether David Ortiz can match those skills. But I have a hunch.

• When scoring a TD in the fourth quarter or a goal in the third period counts more than the same early in the game, then I'll give Ortiz a huge advantage over A-Rod at the plate, which included these finishes in the American League: First in home runs (48) runs (124), slugging (.610), OPS (1.031), second in batting (.318), on-base percentage (.421) third in walks (91), fourth in RBIs (130) and ninth in stolen bases (21).

• Your American League MVP: Alex Rodriguez of the 2005 AL East champion New York Yankees.

THE 2005 NEW YORK YANKEES SEASON

• Everyone who said they knew A-Rod couldn't succeed in New York can now admit they were wrong.

• Gary Sheffield is a P.I.M.P.

• Mariano Rivera should be headed for his fourth career top-three finish in the Cy Young voting. He gave up 12 earned runs all year, and the league hit .177 against him. However, I'm not sure that anyone who pitches 78.1 innings should win the award. Some stat-head will have to do a study involving his effect over average replacement player or something.

• You'd have to look far and wide to find a Yankees fan disappointed in Hideki Matsui through three seasons, but you might be surprised to learn he's hit only 70 home runs (16, 31, 23 — 23.3 per) in those three years.

• Imagine hearing this question back in April and not wanting to throw up at the potential answer: "Who do you think the Yankees should start in Game 3, Chacon, Wang or Small?"

THE 2005 MLB SEASON

• Mark McGwire says he won't talk about steroids ever again. Guess we won't be talking about his Hall of Fame candidacy ever again, either. Wait until that vote comes up. It'll be a huge day in baseball history.

• I was surprised to hear the Mets played a game on Sunday, because I thought the minor-league baseball season ended a month ago.

• Back in April, Jim Caple was the only one of 19 ESPN "experts" to predict that the Yankees would miss the playoffs. Stick with the jokes, Jimbo.

• Back on Aug. 18, Dan Shanoff on ESPN.com had two words for us: "YANKEES. DONE." The man is a prophet!

THE OTHER SEVEN PLAYOFF TEAMS

• Who gives a shit?

Category: Sports | Permalink | Post a Comment (18)


Comments: The 2005 Yankees: How the East Was Won

Bravodo. I dig it Paul, the only caveat is I hate the yinkees, but I do love the passion. At least you guys (90% of yinkee fans I've met) to back up the smack with fact. I just hope the ALCS goes to 7 and that payrod flounders, gotta love Jete's though. Good luck, at least October is going to be fucking exciting, again.

Posted by John L. Williams 32 at October 3, 2005 5:03 AM

Congrats to the Yanks! I always laugh when people still refer to the Cowboys as "America's Team." Baseball is america's game and the Yankees are truly America's Team and have been for a long time.

My Phils are done :(.

Posted by Cass at October 3, 2005 8:25 AM

Cleveland's run of losses, all at home against a team with nothing to play for, including that Friday night game in which I think Chicago's starting outfield consisted of S.D. Jones, Frankie Williams and the Brooklyn Brawler? Biggest choke ever, right?

Ummm...not even close. The biggest choke ever was...well, it doesn't really need to be said around here.

Regardless, I couldn't be happier about the prospect of another Yankee-Sox ALCS. The road to the World Series should run through our cities.

One last note, when the MVP stands for 'Slightly better statistics' and not 'Most Valuable Player' then you can name A-Rod your MVP. Until that day, you and I both know A-Rod isn't even the most valuable player on the Yankees. (IMHO Jeter is)

Posted by monte at October 3, 2005 9:10 AM

Actually, I was thinking that A-Rod isn't the MVP simply because I don't believe he is the MVP on his own team, let alone in the AL. When I think most valuable or irreplacable, I think Mariano Rivera. I think the Yankees can win without A-Rod...but not without Mariano.

But that said, I think all the press is leaning towards A-Rod. The MVP thing reminds me of the push for Best Picture/Actor...seems like whomever sells himself best will win.

Posted by KG at October 3, 2005 10:24 AM

Yeah, it's true, the MVP certainly does not go to the player with the best statistics. Never has, never win. Sometimes, that guy wins the award, but there is no rule saying it has to. ARod can have the fancy new Hank Aaron Award. Leave the MVP to a guy who deserves it, like David Ortiz.

Posted by CJ at October 3, 2005 12:28 PM

I respect your opinion, but this entry made me want to vomit on my shoes.

Posted by stackpat at October 3, 2005 3:19 PM

Without Arod, the Yanks still would have struggled for the AL East. Without Ortiz, the Red Sox would have finished a solid 4th in my company's softball league.

Rivera is the one guy the Yanks can't win without. He should be given an equivilant of a Lifetime Achievement Award. He's been the MVP of the league for the last 10 years.

Posted by Xopher at October 3, 2005 5:17 PM

as a long time reader of both you and the sports guy, lemme just say that although i've loved the drama, i can't stand the thought of another red sox-yankees alcs.

today's column was in a word, vomitous. i'll look forward to checking back once the yankees are done in the postseason, win or lose.

Posted by cubbiephil at October 3, 2005 6:12 PM

Matsui is my favorite player, but I can't take my eyes off Jeter's ass.
Great post today, Paul. Made me laugh out loud a couple times.

Posted by PeeWee at October 3, 2005 6:13 PM

Just as long as someone beats the White Sox.

Posted by lucy at October 3, 2005 6:48 PM

Monte - Don't you remember Paul explaining that the Yankees ALCS loss last year wasn't that big of a choke because the Red Sox were so good?

As someone else put it at the time, Paul whistled past the graveyard last October.

Paul, you are right about A Rod - maybe if A Rod had 39 HR's or something, but he has 48...and how come nobody throws at manny after his bat flips and trots? He cracks me up (especially after he flipped the bat on a foul ball Friday night) but will anybody call him out on it?

Posted by gmac17 at October 3, 2005 9:04 PM

Manny gets to be Manny for the same reason NFL receivers get to do things former linebackers would have laid them out for, penalty of penalty. The pitchers kept giving him a foot, and he took a yard. It's like it's too late to do something about it.

I would rather the Yankees do something about him hitting 420-foot home runs in the first place.

I wrote about the 2004 ALCS right afterward. I didn't duck anything. It was a shitty, sucky loss against a team no one else could take a game from in the entire postseason. It blew, but it was not heartbreaking, as it was in 1995 and 2001, for very different reasons.

I didn't even see the ninth inning of Game 7 last year. It was like getting advance warning that a kick to the nuts was coming. Very different from 1995, 2001, Bobby Thompson's HR, Aaron Boone's HR, etc.

If Notre Dame blows a 35-point second half lead to Navy this season and breaks that 462-game winning streak, you think Irish fans are gonna drive home crying? No, but Navy fans are gonna party like it's 1999 (another year the Yanks busted the Sux in the ALCS).

Posted by Paul Katcher at October 3, 2005 9:22 PM

Deep down everyone wants to see an Red Sox/Yankees ALCS (the battle of whose starting pitching will implode first. A car wreck you can't look away from).. but what is the option? White Sox/Angels? Who cares?

The Red Sox must make it in to the World Series against Houston. Beating Roger is the new goal.

Posted by amy at October 3, 2005 10:37 PM

A Yanks/Sox ALCS followed by a Yanks/Astros World Series (for obvious reasons) would be sensational.

Let's hope it happens.

Posted by Tim Holland at October 4, 2005 12:15 AM

Yes Paul, I do think the ND fans would drive home crying - just like just about every Yankee fan (besides you) was incredibly upset and horrified at the biggest choke in sports history, but you on the other hand "weren't that surprised"...

Posted by gmac17 at October 4, 2005 8:41 PM

You must know different Yankees fans than me. My friends all rank 1995 and 2001 as worse. Sorry to disappoint you. Never saw the final, crushing out. Saw Griffey score. Saw Gonzalez's bloop, when both games were still in play.

Did you see Aaron Boone's HR? I heard people cried, from everyone who I asked in Boston at the time. No one I know cried here last year. I wouldn't hang with those people anyway.

Posted by Paul Katcher at October 4, 2005 11:57 PM

Talk about denial.

No team has ever blown a 3-0 series lead. You guys were 1 out away from a sweep. The Yankees completely fell apart and yet your friends think '95 and '01 were worse? Who are you trying to convince?

Just because you didn't see doesn't mean it didn't happen

Posted by monte at October 5, 2005 10:35 AM

Believe what you want to believe. Maybe in five more years you'll give up trying to convince someone you don't even know how he felt about a sporting event, even if he's already told you 100 times.

Last time I'll go over this. In terms of painful losses:

1. 2001 World Series - Last-inning kick in nuts. Watch Nine Innings on HBO to understand how much this meant to us after 9/11. Just some good news, please. There was nothing else to smile about, for god's sake. If I have to explain this further, god help you.

2. 1995 ALDS - Last-inning kick in the nuts. First time in the postseason. Hadn't seen my team win four World Series yet. That's the difference. The true Yankees fans will always tell you the 1995 ALCS was just insane. Games 1 and 2 had the most electric crowds I've ever seen. Devastating because we didn't know it we were gonna dominate baseball through the end of the century and the start of the next.

3. 2004 ALCS - Slow bleed. Joked with Yanks fans in the eighth of Game 7 about Dave Attell's joke: "You ever make fun of someone for so long you think you should thank them for all the good times you've had?" Timed my walk home in the ninth on the same streets I celebrated four World Series. Lost with Jon Lieber and Kevin Brown at home. Something seemed wrong to begin with. Enjoy so many great Yanks moments that who could complain? The night the Sux beat the Cards, a few friends and I toasted the Babe and 86 good years shot after shot. We laughed and had a blast (and got blasted). Sux were gonna win eventually. Only problem: annoying Sux fans who think we care about Boston as much as they do New York, and that we never enjoyed a baseball moment unless they were involved.

Posted by Paul Katcher at October 5, 2005 11:50 AM
Post a comment
















Fark.com
- [Interesting] Crips and Bloods still keeping it real ... in New Zealand. Wait, what?

- [Amusing] Police searching for teeny tiny gang of horse thieves after 28-inch pony stolen from field (pic)

- [Photoshop] Photoshop these ancient columns

- [Asinine] From the Department of Redundancy Department: Texas issues a report declaring that Texas has too many reports. Bonus: Report is 668 pages long and took 18 months to compile

- [Hero] Woman on crutches rescued from rapist by five bystanders (With scary mugshot goodness)

Yahoo! News: Most Popular
- Palin says 17-year-old daughter is pregnant (AP)

- To rebut rumors, Palin says daughter, 17, pregnant (Reuters)

- Obama Offers a Beautifully Packaged Lie (RealClearPolitics.com)

- Malaysian man gets nut stuck around penis: report (AFP)

- Study: Bypass better than stents in long term (AP)

Yahoo! News: Sports News
- Brady says he's ready to play in Patriots' opener (AP)

- Koby Clemens, 2 other players arrested (AP)

- Go Fish: Unseeded Mardy Fish into US Open quarters (AP)

- Anderson likely to to start opener for Browns (AP)

- Brewers' GM wants changes to scoring system (AP)

Web Friends
News
Sports
New York City
Sex
Internet
Guitar
Powered by Movable Type 3.31.