Home Contact New York News Photos 1 2 Reviews Sports Web Finds
Your Host
Site Tools
Categories
Archive
Greatest Hits
Photos
Interviews
Search



PaulKatcher.com
All of Web
Monday, August 23, 2004

Meet My Horrid Fantasy Football Team
I've been married to Dolphins RB Travis Minor for less than 24 hours and already it's not working out. Wish I'd known he'd gained 15 yards on 13 carries in two preseason games. I also wish I'd known Cardinals RB Marcel Shipp was out for the season. The again, maybe I should have actually prepared for my first of two fantasy football drafts.

Before I evaluate my "talent," here's some key info on my "high school league," 15 years (or thereabouts) running, which I've won twice and missed the playoffs only once in the past decade — and have never been in the year-end Toilet Bowl, reserved for the truly rank.

1. It's an auction league. Teams start with $260, to allot however they wish. Load up on stars and risk season-crippling injuries or go for depth; it's your choice.

2. It's a keeper league. Teams can up to re-sign seven players they drafted or picked up on waivers last year. High-risk players drafted while injured at last year's draft — Michael Vick ($34) and Chad Pennington ($4) — were solid keepers this season. As were guys who last year began the season as back-ups and are now No. 1 on their respective depth charts — Tim Rattay ($1) , Marc Bulger ($7) and Rudi Johnson ($5). Thanks to my horrible draft performance last year — Rich Gannon, Peerless Price, Charles Rogers, Garrison Hearst — I kept absolutely no one.

3. Teams get two "toppers." Owners may not, without challenge, re-sign players they've had under contract for two straight seasons. But they may sit out those players' auctions and elect to "top" the final bid by $1 in order to retain that player's rights. Teams can exercise a maximum of two toppers per draft, which can be frustrating if, for example, you're me and four of your winning bids were topped Sunday night.

4. It's a deep league. Twelve teams need to start two QBs, three RBs and WRs, two TEs, Ks and DEFs. So 24 QBs are on active lineups every week, distinguishing this league from bogus 10-teamers that start one QB. In the late '90s, I used to write a weekly fantasy football column on AOL (@SportsFan Radio's Gridiron Guru) and used to get this kind of question from such owners: "I have Brett Favre, Steve Young, Dan Marino, Drew Bledsoe and John Elway, but I can start only one. Who would you go with?"

Here's how my unit shapes up, with probable starters in bold.

QUARTERBACKS
Drew Bledsoe ($25), Eli Manning ($18) and Kurt Warner ($6), Jay Fiedler ($9)
The Skinny: QBs are most prized on our league and, according to CBS SportsLine's cheat sheet, 13 of the top 17 in the league were kept from last year, including Donovan McNabb at $71. The four available QBs in that group and the prices they garnered: Matt Hasselbeck ($67), Aaron Brooks ($59), Trent Green ($61) and Jeff Garcia ($38). Still stinging from paying $67 for Rich Gannon a year ago, I looked to the bargain bin, hoping for a mini Bledsoe resurgence (20 TDs will do) and anything out of the Giants' offense.

RUNNING BACKS
Tiki Barber ($16), Travis Minor ($16), Jerome Bettis ($9), William Green ($9), Marcel Shipp ($7)
The Skinny: Eight of the top 12 backs were kept, and the ones available went for a pretty penny. LaDainian Tomlinson was the draft's highest-priced player at $73, and Clinton Portis went for $71. Stephen Davis, which SportsLine ranked as the 13th best back and had 1,609 yards from scrimmage and 8 TDs last year, went for $60. I didn't really want Tiki Barber on my team for the 21st straight season, but when his bidding ended at $15, I couldn't use my topper fast enough. He had more yards from scrimmage (1,677) than Davis, albeit only 3 TDs. I didn't know Shipp was out for the season until bidding had stopped and I'd "won," a classic boner move, but my research extended no further than a couple of cheat sheets I printed out two hours before the draft and a magazine I bought in Vegas and opened twice. Minor, Bettis and Green suck. Let's move on.

WIDE RECEIVERS
Terrell Owens ($41), Peerless Price ($19), Rod Smith ($10), Larry Fitzgerald ($12) and Drew Bennett ($4)
The Skinny: I really like my wide receivers, but who doesn't? Every year it's the deepest position and also the one that can pay off huge on the waiver wire. Is there any better feeling than picking a guy up at 11:59 a.m. and seeing him catch a bomb at 1:12 p.m.? Two minutes into the game, and he's done his work for the week. Owens, who I hate, was a topper. By contrast, Randy Moss went for $56 and Marvin Harrison went for $52. Price ruined me last year, but perhaps a healthy Vick will make a huge difference. Smith should be reliable as always. Fitzgerald I overpaid for like an idiot. And Bennett is the best receiver in the NFL — among white guys. I missed out on Amani Toomer and the chance to let my entire season depend on the Giants' offense.

TIGHT ENDS
Tony Gonzalez ($19), Jeremy Shockey ($12), Anthony Becht ($3)
The Skinny: Our league is unique in that each of 12 teams must start two TEs a week, and you can really take a hit here if you get don't quality. Making up 12 points a game in this spot is a lot cheaper than doing it at one of the more high-profile positions, so I was happy to spend $31 on a two-TE combo that, hopefully, will combine for between 14-18 TDs and 1,600 yards. Also, with Owens and Shockey, my team will lead the league in dumbest post-game quotes and crass on-field behavior.

KICKERS
Aaron Elling ($1), Olindo Mare ($1)
The Skinny: I will always remember Syracuse grad Mare for clinching one of my two titles with a 40-yarder late in a Dolphins-Broncos Monday night game. Not as well, however, as I do a another Monday nighter when Jon Gruden accepted a penalty against the Steelers, taking off the board a Martin Gramatica 50-yard field goal that put my team in the Super Bowl. I also had Mike Alstott going, and the Bucs never scored another point. I hate you, Chuckie! Before the draft, I threw back Adam Vinatieri at $3 and ended up with $7 I never used. So one of these kickers could have been Vinatieri, David Akers ($6) or Jeff Wilkins ($6). Did I mention my draft sucked?

DEFENSES
Panthers ($11), Buccaneers ($5)
Good defenses, sure. But $11 might be a record for any defense, and $16 for two is just stupid. But when you figure I paid $7 for a RB out for the year, $12 on a Cardinals rookie receiver, and ended the draft with $7 I never even used, Carolina was a steal. Now watch 'em such this year. And I have to root for Gruden again. Ugh.

Category: Sports | Permalink | Post a Comment (5)


Comments: Meet My Horrid Fantasy Football Team

IS THERE A FANTASY DRUG TEST THAT GOES ALONG WITH THIS?

Posted by HALLAS at August 23, 2004 4:53 PM

We used to have drug tests in our league - and were right on hand to supply some if anyone came back negative.

You took some hits on your team, but you're not that bad off. Having both Eli and Brenda will help when Eli hits the wall in October. Bledsoe could be solid if he finds a new TE to throw to.

Having both Gonz and Shockey is about as good as you could ask for, plus Becht has his moments as well. You might want to try to trade Shockey to someone that is hurting at TE for some depth at RB - maybe try to get package him with Green to whomever has Suggs for an insurance policy. I'd also try to see if you can get someone to bite on Rod Smith before he completely tanks this year.

Of course, I'm the same person who's passed on Curtis Martin for the last three years because I thought he was too old, so what the hell do I know?

BTW - is it obvious yet that I'm jonesing for my draft?

Posted by Rob at August 23, 2004 8:42 PM

This makes my head hurt. This post implies that fantasy football requires thought and planning... I may actually have to figure out how the fantasy football league I'm in works because I refuse to look like a fool.

Posted by amy at August 23, 2004 10:48 PM

amy... I'm guessing your league is a basic draft, not an auction like Paul's. Auctions are a lot more rare, and more antiquated (15 years running makes sense).

I hate having a draft and realizing how much a team sucks. Last year, my QB hopes rode on Tim Couch/Kelly Holcombe. Can you guess how well I did?

If you wanna up your stupid-quote quota (that sounds funny), trade for Kellen Winslow Jr.

Posted by CJ at August 24, 2004 1:59 AM

can't nit pick today, one/won and a couple typos.
not bad for a long article i'd probably make more. I was scared this morning, tried to get my fix of your site today and couldn't get access.
whew! all set

Posted by Danny at August 24, 2004 11:09 AM
Post a comment
















Fark.com
- [Interesting] Crips and Bloods still keeping it real ... in New Zealand. Wait, what?

- [Amusing] Police searching for teeny tiny gang of horse thieves after 28-inch pony stolen from field (pic)

- [Photoshop] Photoshop these ancient columns

- [Asinine] From the Department of Redundancy Department: Texas issues a report declaring that Texas has too many reports. Bonus: Report is 668 pages long and took 18 months to compile

- [Hero] Woman on crutches rescued from rapist by five bystanders (With scary mugshot goodness)

Yahoo! News: Most Emailed
- Los Angeles in a stew over taco trucks (The Christian Science Monitor)

- Edwards gives long-awaited endorsement to Obama (AP)

- Ants swarm over Houston area, fouling electronics (AP)

- McCain's wife sells Sudan-related investments (AP)

- Swiss man soars above Alps with jet-powered wing (AP)

Yahoo! News: Sports News
- Celtics beat Cavs 96-89 to take 3-2 lead in series (AP)

- No. 1 Justine Henin retires from tennis immediately (AP)

- Sen. Specter wants independent investigation into Spygate (AP)

- Stars avoid sweep, send West finals back to Detroit (AP)

- Reds recover for 7-6 win over Marlins in 10 innings (AP)

Web Friends
News
Sports
New York City
Sex
Internet
Guitar
Powered by Movable Type 3.31.