Home Contact New York News Photos 1 2 Reviews Sports Web Finds
Your Host
Site Tools
Categories
Archive
Greatest Hits
Photos
Interviews
Search



PaulKatcher.com
All of Web
Thursday, July 29, 2004

My Favorite Sports Call: 'Hold On to the Roof!'
Earlier this week, SI.com published a huge package on the best sports announcers in every sport. (Strangely, I couldn't find a link to the feature on the site's home page Wednesday night, though you can still find a "body paint" link related to the swimsuit issue that came out several months ago.)

My favorite part of the sport-by-sport rundown was the best calls ever. We'll get to that, but first my reactions to some of the top-5 rankings of play-by-play men and analysts.

• Dr. Z lists Al DeRogatis, whom I've never heard of, as his favorite NFL analyst ever, and John Madden, who may or may not have a crush on Brett Favre, as No. 2. This is where you just say, "It's Dr. Z. He knows more about football than every other NFL writer combined." And you move on.

• Dan Fouts appears in the top analysts for both the NFL and college football. And ya know what? I totally agree. Teaming Dennis Miller with him the Monday Night Football booth was like inviting Zach Hanson to jam with the E. Street Band.

• Tom Verducci lists Joe Torre as the fifth-best baseball analyst. Must've been back when he was a .500 manager for everyone but the Yanks.

• Marv Albert is the top NBA play-by-play man. Probably the strongest slam-dunk in the package.

• Howie Meeker is the top NHL analyst. Um, if you say so. I hate hockey.

• Dick Vitale is nowhere on the college basketball list. Not even an honorable mention. Wonder if they could've gotten away with this on ESPN.com. (Says here no.) Duke fans must be up in arms.

• Jon Wertheim wants to see Snoop Dogg in the booth for tennis broadcasts. Why not get Coolio and MC Hammer in there while you're at it?

And now for the best calls...

My favorite part of the piece is where each writer reflects on the greatest calls in their respective sports.

• For my money, nothing tops Human Jackhammer Gary Thorne's call of Don Mattingly's final home run as a Yankee, a solo shot that broke a tie in Game 2 of the electrifying 1995 ALDS against the Mariners. I was at the game, so I've heard Thorne's warning of "Hold on to the roof!" only on replay. He couldn't have been more accurate. Yankee Stadium went bananas. You'll recall that the game ended on a 15th-inning home run by Jim Leyritz in a steady downpour. Most fans brought umbrellas, and we needed them, as tons of beers came flying out from the upper deck in celebration. That doesn't exactly make sense to me, but if you catch a replay of the moment in Don Mattingly's Yankeeography on YES, you'll see just how much that place was jumping and how many beers were tossed into the air.

• Somehow — and I really can't believe this — Stewart Mandel did not list the call of Cal's miraculous 1982 kick return to beat Stanford as one of the best in college football history. Announcer Joe Starkey barely had any voice left when he yelled, "Oh my god, the most amazing, sensational, traumatic, heart rending, exciting, thrilling finish in the history of college football!" It was a homer call, for sure, but pure, genuine emotion. (Read about it here.) Till the day I die, I'll have no idea how Mandel went with Brent Musburger's call of Ricky Williams' NCAA record-breaking run: "Ricky cuts left ... hello record book!" What would have been even better is Dave Wannstedt's reaction to Ricky's phone call last week. "You're fucking doing what?!"

• Hard to argue with "The Giants win the pennant!" as the top baseball call, but I could listen to Jack Buck exclaiming, after Kirk Gibson's 1988 World Series smash, "I don't believe what I just saw!" all day. It was as if he was telling us to enjoy this gift of shared baseball history. (Audio link in right column.)

• Also have a place in my heart for Al McGuire, who, in 1996, announced the Syracuse Orangemen's upset victory over Kansas in the Elite Eight as such: "Wow, what a win by the Orange!" I almost had a heart attack that day, the first time Syracuse had made the Final Four since my enrollment six years earlier. I videotaped the game and watched Jacque Vaughn's potential game-tying 3-pointer miss maybe 100 times.

And my pick for worst call ever...

• Chris Berman on Cal Ripken's home run on the night he broke Lou Gehrig's record. "OH MY GOODNESS, HE'S DONE IT AGAIN!!!" First, no one says, "Oh, my goodness," anymore. Second, that was the loudest call ever. If someone in the truck had to have been treated for a ruptured ear drum, I would not be surprised. Third, Ripken hit 17 home runs in 144 games in 1995. You're looking at about a 12% chance of him hitting one in that game. That is not the same as Cal running back a kickoff on 20 laterals against Stanford or Duke scoring a game-winner with the ball inbounded across the court with 2.1 seconds left. It was a big deal, but let's not lose out minds over it.

Other Sports Links:

ESPN's Best Coaches of the Last 25 Years — I didn't see the show, so I don't know what reasons were given for ranking Dean Smith No. 1 and Mike Krzyzewski No. 3. Since 1979, when the list is supposed to have been relevant, Smith coached UNC to two national titles and six Final Fours. Duke, under Coach K during that time, won three national titles and went to 10 Final Fours. Basketball, to me, however, seems an easier sport to coach, than, say, football. I'm not saying you can always just roll the ball out, but if you've got a couple of horses, sometimes you can just let them run. For my money, Bill Walsh was the premier coaching mind, if only because he won consistently, even with almost a full turnover of talent, from Wendell Tyler to Roger Craig, from Dwight Clark to Jerry Rice. Montana was a constant, the leading passer for Walsh's final eight seasons, during which the 49ers averaged more than 10.5 wins per season and won three Super Bowl titles. Also of interest: two women's basketball coaches, Pat Summitt (5) and Geno Auriemma (12) rank ahead of baseball's top manager, Joe Torre (13).

Yanks Offer Free Tickets to Active U.S. Military — I was checking out the Yankees' tickets specials for 2004, and one of them is Military Personnel Dates, which basically offers complimentary Tier reserved seats to anyone presenting an active military ID at the advance ticket windows. Nice gesture, King George, ruler of everything right with the game of baseball.

Unit Could Be Yank By Saturday — The New York Post reports: "Many believe the Diamondbacks are posturing when they say there is no match with the Yankees — and that by Saturday they will take a package that includes Triple-A catcher Dioner Navarro, second baseman Robinson Cano and perhaps Scott Proctor and Brad Halsey." The Post you remember, also reported that John Kerry selected Dick Gephardt as his running mate. So take that with a grain of salt. I'd be perfectly happy if Randy Johnson stayed where he is, out of harm's way, as far as the Yankees were concerned. Though, during the brawl Saturday at Fenway, I may have said something to the effect of, "Screw these bitches. I'm sick of our guys getting hit every time they don't like something — a score, a lead in the standings, a guy stepping out of the batter's box when the ump allows him to. Let's get Randy Johnson right now."

Category: Sports | Permalink | Post a Comment (13)


Comments: My Favorite Sports Call: 'Hold On to the Roof!'

Verducci's an idjit. I'd take listening to the Cubs local announcers over the network guys any day of the week. In fact, when the Cubs were playing for the pennant last year we turned off the sound on the tv and turned on 720AM. They, at least, didn't blather on about the most unimportant nonsense and try to be funny to fill time.

Harry Caray and the Giants-Cubs series in '89. Never better. "Let's get some runs!"

Posted by lucy at July 29, 2004 8:55 AM

http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/2004/writers/frank_deford/07/22/announcers/

This whole series is tainted by the fact that McCarver is the #1 analyst for MLB? He is disgraceful.

Even though I wasn't alive yet, the greatest call I ever heard was Johnny Most "Havlicek stole the ball" and I've heard it about a million times. It's one of those Boston folklore moments, I guess.

And no Olympic section? Al "do you believe in miracles" Michaels was robbed!!

Posted by amy at July 29, 2004 10:47 AM

While that list was supposed to be a list of the best announces in any sport, outside of the hockey list it seemed to me they used very little local color, as almost all of them were national network announcers. Where were the local color guys that listeners love or hate? I still tune in to Myron Cope, the world's weirdest football announcer, over the Internet during every Steelers game.

Posted by Pat at July 29, 2004 11:10 AM

amy stole my thunder. The "miracle" call should be #1 on all lists.

And I'd put the Gibson home run call at the top of any baseball list. I'm not a Dodgers fan in the least, but just thinking of that moment still gives me chills.

Posted by CJ at July 29, 2004 11:10 AM

Michaels' Olympics call was in the NHL/hockey section. Like Marv Albert, also a slam dunk.

Posted by Paul Katcher at July 29, 2004 11:12 AM

This is such a bad list.

There is only one passing mention of Cosell, and a negative one at that. His call of the Foreman-Frazier fight, with "Down goes Frazier!" is an all-time classic. He repartee with Ali, his interview of Tommie Smith and John Carlos at the 1968 Olympics right after they did their Black Power salute, his insistence on covering the 1972 Olympics' terrorist attack on the Israeli athletes, his banter with Meredith and Gifford on Monday Night Football, and so much more make him the all-time best.

I believe that Al DeRogatis also did radio for the NY Giants of the NFL, since we are going way back. He was excellent, as I recall, but I didn't listen to much of their radio.

And often overlooked is the odd couple of Bill White and Phil Rizzuto with the Yankees. White made light of Rizzuto but in a respectful and playful way.

Posted by Eddie at July 29, 2004 3:21 PM

I could watch any old Yanks replay, if only to hear Phil Rizzuto again. As for the current guys, I really like Ken Singleton, and Bobby Murcer is a charming, ol' chap to have in the booth, too.

Posted by Paul Katcher at July 29, 2004 3:39 PM

Hey, how come so much beer was being thrown around in the 15th inning of Yanks game. They cut off beer sales in the 7th. Not buyin' it.

Posted by Hey Beer Man at July 29, 2004 11:39 PM

Easy question. Mattingly hit his go-ahead HR in the 6th inning, a back-to-back job that followed Ruben Sierra's homer that tied the game at 2-2.

The M's scored two to take a 3-2 lead in the top of the seventh, and Paul O'Neill tied it with a homer in the bottom half. The M's scored one in the 10th and the Yanks tied it on a two-out hit off the top of the left-field wall. I believe a Yankee was cut down at the plate to end the inning.

Leyritz then hit a two-run homer in the bottom of the 15th. An incredible game to se live, or to see anywhere.

Posted by Paul Katcher at July 30, 2004 12:54 AM

I love Rizzuto and Bill White as a team, grew up with them.But I think Bill White's call of Bucky F'in Dent home run could be one of the worst calls ever.."Deep to left.. and Yaz is not going to get it.."

p.s Rizzuto looks great with all the living Hall of Famers in this week Sports Illustrated. Dont leave us anytime soon Scooter

Posted by Ayan at July 30, 2004 6:27 AM

Acutally, Verducci was right about Al Leiter. When he joined the Fox booth for some games during the playoffs, I really enjoyed his insight to the game. My personal favorites are Dick and Bert, the TV guys of the Twins. I might be a little biased, but not much. These guys are good.

Posted by The 7th Angel at July 30, 2004 9:58 AM

I'm not sure how Pat and Gino got ranked ahead of Torre. They're excellent coaches, but let's face it, women's college hoops hasn't been terribly competitive until recently (and then lots of the competition has been in the UConn/Tenn rivalry). For most of its history, there were just a few top teams and the rest sucked by comparison. Now the quality of teams is coming up across the board, but for a while, it seems like it was kind of easy to keep winning once you had a good team. (I can't explain what happened to Rutgers, though, which once had a great team.)

Plus, Pat and Gino don't have the same kind of coaching issues to deal with that any professional MLB manager has.

I guess in general, I'd question the comparison between coaches in the pros and in college.

[sorry for the rambling post]

Posted by bhw at July 30, 2004 12:14 PM

im so glad you mentioned joe starkey. and especially how out of breath he was. he's like that in literally every game he announces, whether it be for the 49er's or for Cal. it's pretty amazing to listen to. the guy is incredible.

Posted by josh at July 31, 2004 3:56 AM
Post a comment
















Fark.com
- [Interesting] Crips and Bloods still keeping it real ... in New Zealand. Wait, what?

- [Amusing] Police searching for teeny tiny gang of horse thieves after 28-inch pony stolen from field (pic)

- [Photoshop] Photoshop these ancient columns

- [Asinine] From the Department of Redundancy Department: Texas issues a report declaring that Texas has too many reports. Bonus: Report is 668 pages long and took 18 months to compile

- [Hero] Woman on crutches rescued from rapist by five bystanders (With scary mugshot goodness)

Yahoo! News: Most Popular
- Want to live a long life? Run (Reuters)

- Apple, AT&T mum on iPhone 3G issues (CNET)

- Perseid Meteor Shower Peaks Tuesday Morning (SPACE.com)

- Edwards sex lie cost Clinton the nomination: former aide (AFP)

- AP IMPACT: Bush to relax protected species rules (AP)

Yahoo! News: Sports News
- Make room for Phelps as winningest Olympian ever (AP)

- Natalie Coughlin defends Olympic 100 back title (AP)

- Diamondbacks acquire slugger Adam Dunn from Reds (AP)

- Rays place rookie Evan Longoria on 15-day DL (AP)

- Seahawks' Bobby Engram sidelined 6 to 8 weeks (AP)

Web Friends
News
Sports
New York City
Sex
Internet
Guitar
Powered by Movable Type 3.31.