Home Contact New York News Photos 1 2 Reviews Sports Web Finds
Your Host
Site Tools
Categories
Archive
Greatest Hits
Photos
Interviews
Search



PaulKatcher.com
All of Web
Wednesday, April 21, 2004

The Most Impressive Athletic Feat I Ever Saw
This week on the redesigned ESPN.com Page 2, Jeff Merron attempts to answer the question, "Which athletic feat is first?", presenting an argument for the 10 best, which includes Nadia Comaneci's fifth perfect 10, Maradona's most-famous legal goal and Michael Jordan's oft-replayed hand-switching scoop against the Lakers ("A spectacular move by Michael Jordan!" gushed Marv Albert.) Missing from Merron's list is the greatest feat I ever saw, and I don't have to think twice about giving it such praise.

On Thursday, Aug. 1, 1996, at the Atlanta summer Olympics, Michael Johnson set a world record in the 200 meters with a time of 19.32 seconds in the final. (Details and commentary.) That number may not mean much to you — it didn't to me then — but figure in the context:

• Johnson came to Atlanta having set a 200m record with 19.66 in the Olympic trials, besting Pietro Minnea's 200 mark of 19.72 that had stood for 17 years. Almost two decades had passed and world-class athletes had trimmed just 0.06 off the record. In his gold shoes, Johnson whacked 0.32 off his own record, 0.38 faster than any other human in history.

• Barely in the picture to the right, taken by Heinz Kluetmeier for Sports Illustrated, is second-place finisher Frankie Fredericks. His silver-medal time of 19.68 was the third-fastest ever run in the event.

• Johnson ran 0.124274238 miles in 0.00536666667 hours. That's 23.16 miles an hour. Compare that to brisk treadmill runs at 8, 9, even 10 mph. At 23.16 mph, you'd end up in the hospital.

• Johnson's record is not subject to hypothetical debates comparing eras, technological advancements, playing styles, free agency and competition. We'll be arguing the merits of Babe Ruth, Barry Bonds, Jerry Rice, Wayne Gretzky, Jim Brown, the 1960s Packers and Celtics and the 1990s Bulls forever. With Johnson, there is no debate. He blew away history. Period.

• It beats individual plays in many game situations, because who's to say a different athlete in the same unique position could not have achieved the same? Was Jordan's move the most athletic in NBA history? Probably not. Was Dr. J. or is Vince Carter capable of switching hands on a layup? Of course. Take nothing away from such moments, but they're not as pure in terms of one person owning a feat that is absolutely untouchable.

• Speed doesn't slump. Speed doesn't streak. Dale Long set an MLB mark in 1956 by hitting home runs in eight straight games. It wasn't matched until 1987 by Don Mattingly. Obviously, neither is among the greatest home run hitters ever.

My Other Top Feats:

• Secretariat Wins 1973 Belmont Stakes by 31 Lengths — Ranked only No. 7 on ESPN's list, this moment produced one of the most jaw-dropping sports photographs ever, that of jockey Ron Turcotte peering behind him to see if anyone else was even on the track. Secretariat's entry on Wikipedia.org reads, "On his way to a record time in that race (1:59 2/5), he achieved the unheard-of feat of running each quarter-mile segment fractionally faster than the one before it. The quarter-mile times were: 25 1/5, 24, 23 4/5, 23 2/5 and 23."

• Bob Beamon's 1968 long jump, Vince Carter's 2000 slam dunk contest, Rickey Henderson's 130 stolen bases in 1982, Bill Walton goes 21-22 in 1973 NCAA Tournament game, Mickey Mantle's reported 565-foot home run. Almost unfathomable acts of overwhelming athletic prowess.)

Overrated:

• Willie Mays' 1954 Catch: Happened to come in the World Series in a big spot in Game 1, but the varying distances at which Vic Wertz supposedly hit the ball clouds the legitimacy of how incredible a catch it was.

Other Sports Links:

Dr. Z's Draft Memories — Paul Zimmerman recounts the biggest surprises, best strategists and that most amazing 1974 Steelers draft, in which they came away with four future Hall of Famers — Lynn Swann, Jack Lambert, John Stallworth and Mike Webster. (SI.com's NFL mock draft.)

Obsessive Fans Track the National Pastime on the WebSlate surveys the baseball blogs that hope to see plenty of action this summer.

Race Hasn't Left the Ballpark — Longtime civil rights activist Richard Lapchick asserts that the way the public views Barry Bonds proves that "whites and African-Americans still do not look at an event or a person and see the same thing."

Could Bonds Hit .400? — It may be a little early to project, but Bonds is hitting .514 on the season and hit .397 after the All-Star break during the past two seasons. He's slugging 1.378, meaning that walking him in every plate appearance this year would have been the best defense.

Get Your Name on Yankee Stadium Marquee for Only $10 — At this cheap price, I'm gonna have to get my name up there some day. Also, check dates at Shea Stadium when kids can run the bases after games. It's not like the Mets give the infield much of a workout. (Links found on Manhattan User's Guide.)

Category: Sports | Permalink | Post a Comment (14)


Comments: The Most Impressive Athletic Feat I Ever Saw

I did not see Secretariet in person, but from the film that is the most amazing feat I have ever seen. Watching him run is almost mythical (and I am not a horse racing fan or horse enthusiast).

Posted by art at April 21, 2004 9:23 AM

as a kid who loves horses, i agree with secretariat's win... as a kid i audio taped every triple crown race (clunky old cassettes) and would replay the call over and over... mind you, i was only 3 when big red won the race so i couldn't really tape that one... but all in all, still brings my heart into my throat when i see clips... or that image

Posted by erin at April 21, 2004 11:09 AM

As a magazine collector, I can tell you that the 1973 copies of Secretariat on the cover of Sports Illustrated and TIME go for about $75 each, the highest of any issue since that time. Two other TIME issues — Bruce Springsteen in 1975 and John Gotti in 1986 — go for about the same.

Posted by Paul Katcher at April 21, 2004 12:18 PM

Paul, I gotta agree with you on the Secretariat call.

As much as I didn't think it was right for ESPN to place a horse in the top 50 athletes of all time in their Sports Century list, (Secretariat was No. 33) that episode was, by far, the most exciting and compelling to me of any of the top 50 they aired.

Even after 26 years (I think the episode aired in 1999), I got chills watching Big Red thunder down the backstretch. For anyone who doesn't think that 31-length win was impressive must notice how difficult it is to win the Triple Crown. But to do so in the way Secretariat did it... un-freakin'-believable.

As for Michael Jordan's right- to left-hand switch isn't even the best move in NBA Finals history, let alone NBA history.

This is: http://www.nba.com/history/erving_moment.html

Dr. J's move against the Lakers in Game 4 of the 1980 NBA Finals is by far the best move in NBA history. That's the one where Mark Landesberger cut off Dr. J's route to the hoop down the right side. So what does Dr. J do? He leaps out of bounds, swings his right arm out, whips it around the backboard and lays it in on the left side as Kareem Abdul-Jabbar stares in wonder.

If you ever watch the video, note that the Sixers' Bobby Jones just turns around and heads down court as if it were another move. For an article I was writing, I asked Mo Cheeks about Dr. J's move once and he said that Dr. J did stuff like that in practice all the time.

Still. Greatest! Move! Ever!

I could go even further... Larry Bird following his own miss in Game 1 of the 1981 Finals was better than Jordan's.

I think you know the one... Bird takes a jumper for the right wing. He knows the shot is going to be short and right. So as soon as he lets it go, he heads to the baseline, grabs the ball with his right hand, moves it to his left and throws it in left-handed going out of bounds.

Red Auerbach called it the greatest move he'd seen.

OK, I'll stop now.

Posted by Rob at April 21, 2004 1:55 PM

I'm not sure I'll ever understand the hype behind that MJ move. Sure it was graceful and athletic, but really what was the point of it? The shot was hardly contested, yet he switched hands in mid-air and contorted his body! Why not just ram it down for the sure two? It was pretty, but not altogether necessary.

Now, Dr. J's move was an instinctual, desperate masterpiece. He had nowhere to go and made something out of absolutely nothing. Few if any NBA players could recreate that move in an empty gym, let alone pull it off with Hall of Famers defending the basket.

Posted by RP at April 21, 2004 6:09 PM

Signs in Michael Johnson's home town of Kansas City, Kansas read on the highways leading into the city limits:

"Home of Michael Johnson: World's Fastest Human."

Posted by gjoe at April 21, 2004 10:21 PM

My Other Top Feats: "Vince Carter's 2000 slam dunk contest"

This one caught my eye because it so happens I was there. And while I thought the dunks were fantastic, I didn't walk out of the arena thinking I'd witnessed anything astonishing. Reading Paul's entrees, I couldn't see why this made the list.

But then I took a look here:

http://www.ifrance.com/raptorsarchives/vince_carter%202000SDC.htm

I guess some things are better not seen in person.

Posted by Erik at April 22, 2004 12:05 AM

I saw Vince Carter's performance on TV and it remains perhaps the only time when I left off my couch and mouthed, "Oh my god," after a feat that was purely athletic and not dramatic.

What I mean by that is that Aaron Boone's Game 7 home run sent me running out of the bar and down the street because of the drama involved, but Vince sent me off the couch by doing something that I didn't think a human could do.

Posted by Paul Katcher at April 22, 2004 2:52 AM

Amazingly, what I think has to be the greatest athletic feat of all time has yet to be mentioned by anyone here:

On May 25th, 1935, Jesse Owens set three world records and tied a fourth in a *college* track meet, and all within a span of about an hour.

http://www.jesseowens.com/jobio2.html

Posted by Greg White at April 22, 2004 9:13 AM

Moving lower on the day's entries. When kids run the bases at Shea Stadium are the Mets allowed to count them as runs for that day's game? Is that why McKocksmall is happy? He finally got to see some runs after the Mets let some kids round the the bases?

Posted by Larry at April 22, 2004 12:20 PM

Did someone say Bucky Dent?

Posted by PeeWee at April 23, 2004 1:26 AM

I don't think that Willie Mays' catch is more impressive than Johnson, Owens, or Secretariat, but the fact it is overrated because of distance discrepancies? Please. If you watch the video, you can tell he ran a helluva long way for that ball. I don't many could make it there, much less catch the damn thing. And the throw back to 2nd base was amazing too. I still think Johnson in Atlanta was the most amazing though.

Posted by McGuire at April 23, 2004 2:50 AM

My point is that the discrepancies in how far Mays supposedly ran clouds the reality of what actually happened. A guy made an over-the-shoulder catch. Seen others do it a million times. A guy whirled to second base. Not unfathomable. People say Wertz hit the ball either 420 or 450 or 480 feet. Well, which is it, 'cause that means a lot.

I imagine the Polo Grounds was like many of today's NYC skyscrapers. Unless you're standing underneath them, you really don't know how big they are. So perhaps I would have been floored by Mays' catch had I been there. But I wasn't, and I have to rely on empirical evidence, because the film just doesn't look impressive enough to be one of the most athletic feats of all time.

Posted by Paul Katcher at April 23, 2004 3:53 AM

I don't know why I'm getting so rilled up about this, but I am. When you break it down to an over-the-should catch and throw to 2nd base, it doesn't sound that impressive. Today's centerfields are right around 400 feet. The deepest are Minute Maid in Houston and Pro Player in Miami at 435 feet. At the time Mays' catch was, the centerfield fence was at 475, 40 feet farther than today's deepest fence. So obviously the claim of 480 is bogus. Since he caught it just as he reached the warning track, I think 465-470 is about as deep as he could have caught it without hitting the wall. Since most major leage outfielders have problems going back for a ball at 400 ft, running 60-70 extra feet is incredible. He then stopped on a dime, and whipped the ball into the infield so quickly that the guy from second could not score. Men score from second on balls it in the corner. Deep center keeping a man at second from scoring is impressive. He showed 3 tools on that play: running, catching, and throwing. Now nearly every defensive play shows all three, but not all at the level at which Mays displayed them. Now I will grant that over time, I do believe that the catch has grown into a legend that has been distorted. I still think it is one of the greatest feats around.

Posted by McGuire at April 23, 2004 12:43 PM
Post a comment
















Fark.com
- [Interesting] Crips and Bloods still keeping it real ... in New Zealand. Wait, what?

- [Amusing] Police searching for teeny tiny gang of horse thieves after 28-inch pony stolen from field (pic)

- [Photoshop] Photoshop these ancient columns

- [Asinine] From the Department of Redundancy Department: Texas issues a report declaring that Texas has too many reports. Bonus: Report is 668 pages long and took 18 months to compile

- [Hero] Woman on crutches rescued from rapist by five bystanders (With scary mugshot goodness)

Yahoo! News: Most Emailed
- Death toll in China earthquake up to nearly 9,000 (AP)

- Families will make case for vaccine link to autism (AP)

- Sendler, savior of Warsaw Ghetto children, dies (Reuters)

- Why Do People Sleepwalk? (LiveScience.com)

- Australian pokes great white shark in eye (AFP)

Yahoo! News: Sports News
- Kirilenko stuffs Kobe, Lakers in OT as Jazz tie series 2-2 (AP)

- Tim Duncan scores 22 as Spurs beat Hornets 100-80 (AP)

- Garcia ends drought with playoff win at Players Championship (AP)

- Max Talbot pushes Penguins past Flyers for 2-0 series lead (AP)

- Report: USC guard O.J. Mayo got cash, benefits from promoter (AP)

Web Friends
News
Sports
New York City
Sex
Internet
Guitar
Powered by Movable Type 3.31.