Home Contact New York News Photos 1 2 Reviews Sports Web Finds
Your Host
Site Tools
Categories
Archive
Greatest Hits
Photos
Interviews
Search



PaulKatcher.com
All of Web
Thursday, February 20, 2003

Is This the Most Famous Photo Ever Taken?
Last week, for a work project that chronicles the last 80 years of history, I sought out Joe Rosenthal's Pulitzer Prize-winning photo of a flag-raising on Iwo Jima in 1945. As a genuinely curious guy who feels that life is wasted if nothing original is left behind, I did a little research on the history of the one of the most impactful photographs ever shot. (C'mon people, and I don't think about sex every minute of the day.)

In 1995, the AP published a fantastically insightful story on the 50th anniversary of the photo that changed Rosenthal's life in 1/400th of a second on Feb. 23, 1945 at 1:05 p.m. It chronicles the photog's decades-long battle to defend his name against those who say the photo was staged, since the famous flag-raising was not the first of the day. It was a replacement of a smaller one.

When asked if the photo was posed, Rosenthal said that it was. The problem was that he was thought someone was asking about a different picture — a "gung-ho" shot of Marines celebrating on the summit together. Such was the horror of WWII. Even the moments of jubilation had 6,821 dead Americans at their feet.

There were other controversies, such as whether a second flag-raising should be given as much historical importance as it did. A moot point, in my opinion. Five of the 11 men who participated in the two flag-raisings never left Iwo Jima. That's what people should remember about World War II.

What are photos that you remember as the most familiar or impactful of all-time? Post a comment below.

Other Photojournalism Links:

The Pulitzer Prize Photographs: Capture the Moment — Rosenthal's shot leads the online project.

AP's Photos of the 20th Century — No Iwo Jima. What's up with that?

Remembering Alfred Eisenstaedt — The life and work of the famed LIFE photographer. Includes the famous V-J Day kiss in Times Square, which I consider the second-most familiar photo of the 20th Century. Also see LIFE's Images of the Century.

Best American Journalism of the 20th Century — As voted on by a panel of experts assembled by New York University's journalism department. Rosenthal's photo comes in at No. 68. Watergate investigation is No. 3. Truman Capote's landmark book In Cold Blood — one of my favorites ever — is at No. 22.

James Nachtwey's 9/11 Photos — I'm a little cynical when I think about at the photojournalists running to the WTC on 9/11. They weren't going to save lives. And I know of their typical difficulty when it comes to protecting photo rights online. (If it's so honorable and valuable to society, I ask, why worry about someone downloading them?) But I know, I know, that Nachtwey puts himself in harm's way to detail for the world what most are not brave enough to see for themselves. These shots are stunning. And he shot these before and after ducking into a building that went pitch black. I was told he crawled over bodies to get out. How can you be cynical about that? There is a documentary about him titled War Photographer.

Category: News | Permalink | Post a Comment (16)


Comments: Is This the Most Famous Photo Ever Taken?

Although I can't recall any one specific photo, photographs taken during the Vietnam war era moved and facinated me, whether it be soldiers in Vietnam or protests on the homefront.

Posted by Jailbird at February 20, 2003 9:29 AM

there are a couple that i would add; these aren't necessarily the best representations of the pictures, but i gave it a shot:

the berlin wall coming down
http://www.dieberlinermauer.de/berlinwallhome/wall30/wall30.html

john john saluting his father's casket
http://www.boston.com/news/packages/jfkjr/johnkennedy_bio.htm

the challenger explosion
http://free-stock-photos.com/science/challenger-4.html

the five presidents at nixon's funeral
http://www.nixonfoundation.org/Research_Center/Nixons/images/RichardNixonFuneral-140.jpg

just some fodder for the pictoral fire

tk

Posted by tara at February 20, 2003 10:47 AM

You should go over to the International Center of Photography, www.icp.org

Some photographers to put on your list that had shows there I saw:

"Bill Biggart: Final Exposures" -- the only photographer to die on 9/11, they exposed his film and processed his digtal camera pix posthumously. And around the room of the last photos he took before dying, they had his melted camera and camera bag, ID cards, cell phone smashed up. Powerful doesn't begin to describe it.

"Weegee" -- the greatest of all NYC street photographers. His crime photos from 1935-1945 are legend. I particularly like the drunk passed out under a funeral home awning on Amsterdam.

I could go on and on, but ICP is one of my favorite museums in the city.

Posted by kevin at February 20, 2003 11:00 AM

Chronolically (well, mostly):

A smodering WTC captured current affairs as we now set on the brink of war.

The trapped miners who demonstrated that faith and teamwork can overcome insurmountable odds.

Elian Gonzalez in the closet at gunpoint epitomizes the state of affairs of the country in the waning moments of Bubba's administraion.

The Monica press photo that was ubiquitous and symbolized the cowardice of the leader of the free world.

The falling of the Berlin wall which announced the beginning of the end of communism. (I was there in the summer of '90 chipping away at it using a hammer and chisel rented to me by an East German Army mand)

Challenger

The Iranian Hostages

3-Mile Island

The last US helo out of Saigon

Nixon resigns

Pictures of James Dean and Elvis Presley.

The sailor kissing the girl in Times Square when it was announced that the war was over.

The smiling photo of Truman.

That haunting photo of the Normandy invasion.

A burning Pearl Harbor.

That photo of Hitler on the brink of his invasion of Poland.

Any picture of Auschwitz and the like.

The Dust Bowl and the Great Depression

The Wright Brothers at Kitty Hawk

Any Civil War battlefield.

And many, many, many more that represent the state of affairs for that era or a turning point in our history.

-JC in Houston

Posted by JC at February 20, 2003 12:59 PM

How about the lone student in the white shirt standing in defiance of a 17 tank column in Tiananmen Square.
Taken on a day when 156 innocent people lost their lives for freedom. They weren't carrying guns, they didn't have on military fatigues. Dressed only in Black Slacks, a white shirt with a grocery bag in his hand this one man was able to stop 17 tanks. For what? Freedom.

Posted by Shay at February 20, 2003 1:50 PM

Excellant point. That picture of the student in front of the tank was powerful stuff.

Posted by JC at February 20, 2003 2:47 PM

Nobody mentioned any sports photos, which is funny, considering Katcher is more Cosell than Cronkite.

Babe Ruth leaning on his bat during farewell.

Lou Gehrig giving "luckiest man" speech.

Wille Mays making over-the-back catch in Series.

Jackie Robinson stealing home.

Those are all New York teams and baseball, but that's all that matters to me.

Posted by kevin at February 20, 2003 3:02 PM

All of these are great events, but I mean great photos, like THE V-J Day Kiss, like THE Kent State pic (view here).

I don't know that there is a defining photo of the Berlin Wall crumbling. I don't know that there is a defining photo from 9/11.

The Tiananmen Square photo (view here)? That's exactly what I'm talking about.

He was recognized as one of the TIME 100 Leaders & Revolutionaries. The Unknown Rebel, he was called. Without that photo, I'm not sure the legend would exist.

That was photography's effect on culture.

Posted by Paul Katcher at February 20, 2003 3:28 PM

Some not yet mentioned:

The Vietnamese girl running down the road naked, burned from napalm;

The very young, beautiful girl in her wedding dress who had just married the future King of England that represented a fairytale come to life;

Martin Luther King, Jr. as he stood before the crowd in DC and gave his famous speech;

Stalin, Roosevelt, and Churchill at Yalta;

The rows upon rows of graves at Normandy;

The middle-aged man standing at the newly constructed Vietnam memorial;

Rosie the Riveter;

Jackie Kennedy standing next to Johnson, still in her blood stained suit, while he was sworn into office;

could go on and on.....

Posted by lucy at February 20, 2003 7:49 PM

Wow. Those pulitzer photos are something else. Very cool. Thanks.

Posted by Evil Monkey at February 20, 2003 8:53 PM

Kevin Carter, here is his story:

http://home-4.tiscali.nl/~t892660/msp/time.htm

He won the Pulitzer Prize for taking a photo of a famine stricken child in Sudan, in the background is a vulture waiting for the child's demise. Soon after the photo was taken the child perished. It's a story of tragedy in a world of despair. A Pulitzer prize meant nothing to him in the face of rotten hardship.

Posted by Odacious at February 20, 2003 9:45 PM

blackie the cat
ha

Posted by punchy at February 21, 2003 11:40 AM

i am a certified photo fanatic so here is my list of the most famous photos ever taken (non sports) :1. iwo jima 2. napalm girl 3. sailor kiss in times sq 4. john john salute 5. churchill photo by karsh 6. kent st massacre 7. earthrise fr the moon 1968 8. afghan girl 1985 9. viet cong assass 10. lee harvey gets rubbed out 11-24-63 will work on sports list

Posted by ed marcus at September 21, 2004 2:24 PM

i am a certified photo fanatic so here is my list of the most famous photos ever taken (non sports) :1. iwo jima 2. napalm girl 3. sailor kiss in times sq 4. john john salute 5. churchill photo by karsh 6. kent st massacre 7. earthrise fr the moon 1968 8. afghan girl 1985 9. viet cong assass 10. lee harvey gets rubbed out 11-24-63 will work on sports list

Posted by ed marcus at September 21, 2004 2:24 PM

the 10 most famous sprots photos ever taken are after years of research :
1. ali anchor punch
2. babe ruth bows out
3. michael jordans last shot 1998
4. vince lombardi carried off the field sb ii
5. wilt scores 100
6. mazeroski mob scene at home plate wins '60 series
7. dwight clarks catch 1981
8. willie mays catch 1954
9. marciano punch rearranges ezzard charles face
10. ben hogan's comeback
apologies to lou gehrig,ty cobb,1980 olympic team, paul henderson and the black fists at the 1968 olympics

Posted by ed marcus at September 21, 2004 2:31 PM

I am looking for my choice of the most memorable photo that I have ever seen (I am 80). It was taken, I believe at the Metropliton or Carnegie Hall and was of an old old lady decked out in a Kings ransom of jewels and furs and alongside her was an old bag lady or homeless person giving the rich lady a look that has haunted me ever since. I thought that it was a LIFE cover but I guess it wasn't. The picture was taken in the late 30's because I was a youngster when I saw it. I saw it again years later as the subject of famous photos but don't remember the program. I sure would like to locate a copy of that photo.

Posted by lannie1 at August 14, 2006 6:28 PM
Post a comment
















Fark.com
- [Interesting] Crips and Bloods still keeping it real ... in New Zealand. Wait, what?

- [Amusing] Police searching for teeny tiny gang of horse thieves after 28-inch pony stolen from field (pic)

- [Photoshop] Photoshop these ancient columns

- [Asinine] From the Department of Redundancy Department: Texas issues a report declaring that Texas has too many reports. Bonus: Report is 668 pages long and took 18 months to compile

- [Hero] Woman on crutches rescued from rapist by five bystanders (With scary mugshot goodness)

Yahoo! News: Most Emailed
- Los Angeles in a stew over taco trucks (The Christian Science Monitor)

- Edwards gives long-awaited endorsement to Obama (AP)

- Ants swarm over Houston area, fouling electronics (AP)

- McCain's wife sells Sudan-related investments (AP)

- Swiss man soars above Alps with jet-powered wing (AP)

Yahoo! News: Sports News
- Celtics beat Cavs 96-89 to take 3-2 lead in series (AP)

- No. 1 Justine Henin retires from tennis immediately (AP)

- Sen. Specter wants independent investigation into Spygate (AP)

- Stars avoid sweep, send West finals back to Detroit (AP)

- Reds recover for 7-6 win over Marlins in 10 innings (AP)

Web Friends
News
Sports
New York City
Sex
Internet
Guitar
Powered by Movable Type 3.31.